DAR File No. 38271

This rule was published in the February 15, 2014, issue (Vol. 2014, No. 4) of the Utah State Bulletin.


Environmental Quality, Water Quality

Rule R317-5

Large Underground Wastewater Disposal (LUWD) Systems

Notice of Proposed Rule

(Repeal and Reenact)

DAR File No.: 38271
Filed: 01/31/2014 12:06:01 PM

RULE ANALYSIS

Purpose of the rule or reason for the change:

The purpose of this filing is to repeal the existing Rule R317-5 by replacing old language and awkward organization with newer concepts and technologies, referencing Rule R317-4 in similar subsections and parallel rules.

Summary of the rule or change:

Some highlights of the new rule include: 1) the new draft is not a "stand-alone" rule. It incorporates specific provisions in the new Rule R317-4 that are also pertinent to Large Underground Wastewater Disposal (LUWD) systems. These include: a) definitions; b) material standards; c) horizontal setbacks shown in Table 2 in Rule R317-4; d) soil exploration pits and percolation tests; e) design requirements; f) construction and installation; and g) final inspection; 2) outline and contents of new draft closely resemble Rule R317-4; 3) the addition of new authority and purpose sections to comply with format of other rules; 4) the scope section details where an engineer needs to consider factors in design such as flow, waste strength, site characteristics, etc.; 5) emphasis on sound engineering concepts needed for designing these large wastewater systems in more sensitive areas of the state with shallow groundwater or poorer soils being mindful of the increased design flows (over 5,000 pgd); 6) the entire rule has waiver capability granted by the director as long as the proposal does not override "the safeguarding of public health, protection of water quality, or engineering practice"; 7) twelve new definitions with LUWD systems language are included; 8) the new section titled General Standards, Prohibition, Requirements and Enforcement closely resembles Rule R317-4; 9) the new section Feasibility Determination and Concept Approval closely resembles the part of Rule R317-4 that are also pertinent to LUWD systems. In the old rule, no direction was given for applications for approval in concept. All new applications will have to obtain a feasibility determination prior to applying for a construction permit. This will include: a) number of soil logs and percolation tests required (it was unclear in the old rule); b) ground water determination (nothing previously specified; c) ground slope detailed up to 35%, using the same language as Rule R317-4; 10) Engineering Reports, Plans and Construction Permits includes more details about contents of reports and plans that are needed for DWQ review: a) must be designed by a Utah PE and certified Level 3 Onsite Professional per R317-11; details in applications closely resemble Rule R317-4; 11) the Design Requirements section references incorporation of Rule R317-4, with two minor exceptions, and details components required for a LUWD system (same as existing Rule R317-5). Horizontal separation distance between bottom of absorption trenches and anticipated highest ground water table is increased to 48 inches, unless pre-treatment unit is installed, then the separation can be 24 inches; 12) construction and installation is a new section that incorporates Rule R317-4 as a reference; 13) final Inspection and Authorization to Use inspection section references Rule R317-4 and the requirements are more clearly explained when compared to the old version; 14) operation and maintenance section has been overhauled. Closely resembles Rule R317-4 using the same frequency and inspection components; and 15) the section of the Operating Permits and Annual Inspection Reports has been removed which details what information is required to submit in order to obtain an operating permit on existing systems. This is no longer necessary as all LUWD systems have been identified and have operating permits. The rest of this section has the same language as the existing rule, explaining operating permits for new systems and annual inspection reports. Details on the inspection report with new fields to record septic tank measurements, pressure squirt height, date of last pumping, etc., which were all previously required on an operating permit.

State statutory or constitutional authorization for this rule:

  • Title 19, Chapter 5

Anticipated cost or savings to:

the state budget:

No impact to state budget is anticipated. Design of large underground wastewater systems are made by the private sector representing the engineering community and their clients.

local governments:

This rule offers the Local Health Departments (LHDs) some aspects of administration of these systems, but it is strictly voluntary. Those LHDs not wanting to participate, which represent a majority of the counties in Utah, will still have the Division of Water Quality being the lead in review and administration. For those few counties asking for this authority, local ordinances with application fees should cover any of their costs.

small businesses:

As additional lots are developed, businesses involved in the design and construction of large underground wastewater disposal systems may show an increased need for their services and products.

persons other than small businesses, businesses, or local governmental entities:

This rule should not add any additional costs from the present rule. There is language that allows an engineer to seek a waiver from any section of this rule, provided sound engineering and equivalent environmental and public health protection is met.

Compliance costs for affected persons:

No difference in compliance costs is anticipated for affected persons since the overall requirements are nearly identical to the original rule, but have been better organized for easier reference.

Comments by the department head on the fiscal impact the rule may have on businesses:

There is no difference in the fiscal impact expected on businesses since most of the proposed changes are in rule organization and clarity.

Amanda Smith, Executive Director

The full text of this rule may be inspected, during regular business hours, at the Division of Administrative Rules, or at:

Environmental Quality
Water QualityRoom DEQ, Third Floor
195 N 1950 W
SALT LAKE CITY, UT 84116

Direct questions regarding this rule to:

  • Judy Etherington at the above address, by phone at 801-536-4344, by FAX at 801-536-4301, or by Internet E-mail at jetherington@utah.gov

Interested persons may present their views on this rule by submitting written comments to the address above no later than 5:00 p.m. on:

03/17/2014

This rule may become effective on:

03/24/2014

Authorized by:

Walter Baker, Director

RULE TEXT

R317. Environmental Quality, Water Quality.

[R317-5. Large Underground Wastewater Disposal Systems.

R317-5-1. General.

1.1 SCOPE: These rules shall apply to large underground disposal systems for domestic wastewater discharges which exceed 5,000 gallons per day (gpd) and all other domestic wastewater discharges not covered under the definition of an "Onsite wastewater disposal system" in R317-1-1.13. Usually these systems should not be designed for over 15,000 gpd. In general, it is not acceptable to dispose of industrial wastewater in an underground disposal system.

1.2 ENGINEERING REPORT: An engineering report shall be submitted which shall contain design criteria along with all other information necessary to clearly describe the proposed project and demonstrate project feasibility.

1.3 SUBMISSION OF PLANS FOR REVIEW: Plans for new large underground wastewater disposal systems or extensions of existing systems shall be submitted to the Director for review as required by R317-1. All designs shall be prepared and submitted under the supervision of a registered professional engineer licensed to practice in the State of Utah and certified pursuant to R317-11. A construction permit must be issued by the Director prior to construction of the wastewater disposal system or the building(s) to be served by the wastewater system. The system designer must, following construction of the system, certify in writing that the system was installed in accordance with the approved plans and specifications.

A. Local Health Department Requirements - it is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the Large Underground Wastewater Disposal System (LUWDS) application to the Division is in compliance with local health department requirements reqarding the location, design, construction and maintenance of an LUWDS prior to the applicant submitting a request for a construction permit to the Director. Local Health Departments may petition the Director to require local review for compliance with local requirements prior to DWQ initiating its review. Where the petition has been approved by the Director, the applicant is required to submit documentation that the local health department has approved the proposed LUWDS prior to issuance of a construction permit.

1.4 OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE: Operation and maintenance shall be provided by the owner to ensure the disposal system is functioning properly at all times. An operating permit will be required for all large underground wastewater disposal systems to monitor that proper operation and maintenance is occurring for the protection of the environment and public health. The operating permit shall be issued by the Director or, by delegated authority, by the local health department having jurisdiction, and shall be effective for a period not to exceed 5 years from the issuance date.

A. Operating Permit Required: The owner of a large underground wastewater disposal system shall provide a written notice of intent (NOI) to the Division of Water Quality and the local health department having jurisdiction of its intent to operate a large underground wastewater disposal facility. Those systems currently in operation must submit the NOI no later than January 1, 2010. New systems permitted under this rule must submit the NOI prior to final inspection. The notice of intent shall be specific for the operating permit and shall include the following information:

1. Facility name and address; owner name, address, and phone number.

2. List of Facility Components, e.g., septic tank, pump tank, gravel drainfield trench, gravelless chambers, pressure drainfield, etc.

3. Design flow (gallons per day) and number and type of connections.

4. Type of waste treated and disposed, i.e., residential, restaurant, other commercial establishment, etc.

5. Sketch plan of existing system showing major facility components.

B. Local Health Department Authority to Issue Operating Permits:

1. A local health department that currently has approval from the Director to administer an alternative systems program may obtain authority within its jurisdiction to administer operating permits for large underground wastewater disposal systems by submitting a written request to administer this program. The request must include an agreement to implement and enforce inspection, servicing, monitoring, and reporting requirements of this rule.

2. Local health departments that have been delegated authority to administer the operating permit program must submit an annual report on or before September 1 of the calendar year, to the Division of Water Quality containing:

(a) A list of LUWD systems under delegation.

(b) A summary listing the compliance status of each system, showing those systems that are currently failing, and those systems that have been repaired.

(c) A summary of any enforcement actions taken, identifying those actions that are still pending, and those that been resolved.

C. Annual Report. The owner shall summit an annual covering the period of July 1 to June 30 (the "reporting year") to the permitting agency no later than August 1 of each year. In this report, the owner shall report the following items:

1. All information required to be submitted in the NOI.

2. Checklist of inspections performed including the date of the inspection and a list of findings.

3. Packed Bed media system sampling results.

4. Signature of owner or certified operator, and date.

D. Owner Responsibility to Maintain System: The owner is responsible for maintaining its large underground wastewater disposal system and for performing periodic inspections and servicing of its system. Inspections of conventional systems (gravity, or pump to gravity) shall be not less than once each reporting year, and inspections of at-grade, pressure, mound and packed bed media systems shall be not less than twice each reporting year. At a minimum, the owner is responsible for inspecting these components of the various type of system:

1. Community septic tank or treatment unit - measure sludge and scum levels, and pump when necessary.

2. Effluent filter - clean when necessary.

3. Inspect distribution box.

4. Inspect pump, floats, alarm and control panel, and record flow or hour meter reading.

5. Disposal field - inspect for ponding or surfacing in disposal area. Flush, clean, re-adjust to equal pressure in laterals.

E. Operation and Maintenance Manual Required: New systems must have a written operation and maintenance document describing the treatment and disposal system and outlining routine maintenance procedures, including checklists and maintenance logs needed for proper operation of the system. This document must be available at the time of the final inspection on all new systems.

F. Packed Bed Media System Sampling and Monitoring Requirements:

The owner of a packed bed media system is responsible for sampling and monitoring for COD (Chemical Oxygen Demand), TSS (Total Suspended Solids) and TIN (Total Inorganic Nitrogen) at an interval not exceeding six calendar months. Additional sampling and monitoring may be required if it has been determined that there is a potential for groundwater impacts. Effluent quality of a grab sample, before discharge to a disposal method, shall not exceed 75 mg/L COD or 25 mg/L TSS.

1. Effluent COD exceeding 75 mg/L or TSS exceeding 25 mg/L shall be followed up with weekly sampling commencing within 30 days until such time as two successive results are obtained that are within these limits. Any two successive samples resulting in exceedence of either 75 mg/L COD or 25 mg/L TSS shall result in the system being deemed non-compliant requiring further evaluation and a corrective action plan.

2. For non-complying systems, the permitting agency shall require the order:

(a) all necessary steps such as maintenance servicing, repairs, and/or replacement of system components to correct the system;

(b) effluent quality testing for COD and TSS shall continue every week until two successive samples of COD and TSS are found to be in compliance;

(c) payment of fees for additional inspections, reviews and testing;

(d) evaluation of the system design including non-approved changes to the system, the wastewater flow, and biological and chemical loading to the system;

(e) investigation of household practices related to the discharge of chemicals into the system, such as photo-finishing chemicals, laboratory chemicals, excessive amount of cleaners or detergents, etc.; and

(f) additional tests or samples to troubleshoot the system malfunction.

1.5 LARGE UNDERGROUND WASTEWATER DISPOSAL SYSTEM REQUIRED:

The drainage system of any building or establishment covered herein shall receive all wastewater as required by R309-100, the Utah Plumbing Code and shall have a connection to a public sewer except when such sewer is not available for use, in which case connection shall be made as follows:

A. To an underground wastewater disposal system found to be adequate and constructed in accordance with requirements stated herein.

B. To any other type of disposal system acceptable under R317-3.

1.6 MULTIPLE UNITS UNDER SEPARATE OWNERSHIP: Multiple Units Under Separate Ownership shall not be served by a common large underground disposal system except when, based upon sound engineering judgment, other alternatives are determined infeasible. In such cases, a common subsurface system may be used provided the following requirements are met:

A. The common subsurface disposal system and conveyance sewers shall be under the sponsorship of a body politic.

B. The subsurface absorption system shall be designed and constructed to provide duplicate capacity (two independent systems). Each system shall be designed to accommodate the total anticipated maximum daily flow. The duplicate systems shall be designed with appropriate valving, etc., to allow for periodic alternation of the use of each system.

C. Sufficient land area with suitable characteristics shall be available to provide for a third absorption system capable of handling the total maximum daily wastewater flow. This area shall be kept free of permanent structures, traffic or soil modification (See Section R317-5-3.1(L)).

D. The subsurface absorption system should be used only until a more permanent system becomes available.

1.7 NEW PROCESSES AND METHODS OF DISPOSAL: Where unusual conditions exist, other methods of disposal not described herein may be employed if approved by the Director and by the local health authority having jurisdiction. The approval will be based on evidence of adequacy to meet water quality standards and other requirements of the Code.

1.8 UNITS REQUIRED IN A LARGE UNDERGROUND WASTEWATER DISPOSAL SYSTEM: The large underground wastewater disposal system shall typically consist of the following:

A. A building sewer with cleanout.

B. A septic tank.

C. An effluent filter.

D. A pressurized subsurface disposal system. This may be an absorption field, deep wall trenches, absorption beds, or, for packed bed media applications, drip irrigation dispersal, depending on location, topography, soil conditions and maximum ground water level.

E. Accessibility components to insure proper maintenance and servicing. These may include risers on tanks to the surface of the ground, with firmly secured lids; and absorption field inspection ports.

F. Pressurized systems typically require a dosing chamber or dosing tank and cleanouts at the end of pressurized laterals.

G. Additional components may also be required depending on the waste stream characteristics and the need to provide adequate protection to groundwater. These components may include pretreatment devices such as grease traps, or may involve secondary treatment using packed bed media systems.

1.9 LOCATION AND INSTALLATION: Location and installation of the wastewater disposal system shall be such that with reasonable maintenance it will function properly and will not create a nuisance, health hazard or endanger the quality of any waters of the State. Due consideration shall be given to the size and shape of the area in which the system is installed, slope of natural and finished grade, soil characteristics, maximum ground water elevation, proximity of existing or future water supplies or water courses, possible flooding and expansion potential of the disposal system.

1.10 ISOLATION: The system shall be isolated as shown in Table 5-1.

 

TABLE 5-1

  
MINIMUM HORIZONTAL SEPARATION IN FEET
(Undisturbed Earth)

                   Building Septic Absorption Seepage Absorption
                   Sewer    Tank   Field      Pit or  Bed
                                   Trench     trench

Drinking Water
Supply Source
  Deep Well        (a)100   100    100        100     100
  Shallow Well
    or Spring        (b)    (b)    (b)        (b)     (b)
  Domestic Water
    Supply Lines     (c)     10     10         10      10

Ponds, Lakes,
Reservoirs and
Water Courses        ---     25    (d)         (d)    (d)

Foundation Walls      3       5     25         25      25

Land Drain
  Located upslope    ---     10     20         20      20
  Located
    downslope        ---     25    100        100     100

Property Line         5       5      5         15      10

Seepage Pits
(Trenches)           ---      5     10         12(e)   10

Absorption beds      ---      5     10         10      10

Absorption fields    ---      5     (f)        10      10

     Footnotes:
     (a)  Sewers may be constructed within the 100 foot
protective zone, provided the sewer construction meets the
requirements of R309-106-2.3.4.
     (b)  It is recommended that the listed concentrated
sources of pollution be located at least 1,500 feet from
shallow wells and springs.  Any proposal to locate closer than
1,500 feet will be reviewed on a case-by-casebasis, taking into
account geology, topography, existing land use agreements,
designated use of water system (public or non-public) and
potential for pollution of water sources.  It is the
responsibility of the water supply owner to establish an
adequate protection zone in accordance with the applicable
drinking water rules.  Even separation of 1500
feet or greater from concentrated sources of pollution will not
guarantee suitability of the water supply system.
     (c)  The requirements stated in R317-5-1.13(F) must be met.
     (d)  A minimum of 100 feet is desirable, but may be
modified to a lesser or greater distance, depending on soil
conditions or mitigating measures such as lining the water
course with impervious material.
     (e)  Seepage pits or seepage trenches must be installed
within an established absorption zone.  The absorption zone
will be sized based on the ratio of ground surface area "GSA"
to the required sidewall area "SWA".  The GSA/SWA ratio must
be at least 2.5.  The trenches and pits shall be installed
within the absorption zone such that the spacing between
trenches will be equal.  Spacing of 12 feet (sidewall to
sidewall) shall be a minimum.  Distance to the edge or
boundary of the established absorption zone shall be a minimum
of 15 feet.  The system must also conform to all other
separation requirements identified in Table 5-1.
     The required sidewall area "SWA" shall be computed based
on the design application rate with the associated soil type
depicted in Table 5-8.  The ground surface area identified
within the absorption zone will be a minimum of 2.5 times the
required sidewall area.  An example of a typical seepage
trench design with variation is available from the
Division.
     (f)  See Table 5-4.

 

1.11 CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION: Approval to operate the constructed/installed facilities shall be issued following a final inspection by a representative of the Department of Health. The facilities must be inspected after installation but prior to backfilling.

1.12 CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS: Materials used in construction of the system shall be durable, sound, and not unduly subject to corrosion. Pipe, pipe fittings and similar materials shall comply with the requirements of R309-100.

1.13 WASTEWATER DRAINAGE LINE OR BUILDING SEWER: Wastewater drainage lines (or building sewers) shall comply with R309-100, the Utah Plumbing Code, or meet the following requirements, whichever is more restrictive.

A. Any generally accepted material will be given consideration, but material selected shall be suitable for local conditions to include soil characteristics, external loadings, abrasions and similar problems.

B. The lines shall have a minimum inside diameter of 4 inches, in which case they shall be laid on a minimum slope of 1.25 percent. For sewer lines serving more than one dwelling unit, it is recommended that the line be sized greater than 4 inches in diameter. Lines of greater sizes should be designed for a minimum velocity of 2 feet per second based on the pipe flowing full. See R317-3 for calculation of flow velocities.

C. The lines shall have cleanouts every 50 feet and at all changes in direction or grade, except where manholes are installed every 400 feet and at every change in direction or grade.

D. On 4-inch and 6-inch lines, two 45 degree bends with cleanout will be acceptable in lieu of a manhole, and 90 degree ells are not recommended.

E. The design of wastewater pump stations shall comply with the requirements contained in R317-3.

F. Lines shall be separated from water service pipes in separate trenches and by at least 10 feet horizontally. If the local conditions prevent a 10 foot separation, or when sewer lines must cross water lines, the two lines may be placed within the 10 feet of each other, provided:

1. The bottom of the water service pipe, at all points, shall be at least 18 inches above the top of the wastewater drainage line at its highest point.

2. The water service pipe shall be placed in a separate trench or the line should be placed on a shelf of undisturbed soil to one side of the sewer line trench.

3. The number of joints in the service pipe shall be kept to a minimum and the materials and joints of both the sewer line and water service line shall be of a strength and durability to prevent leakage under known adverse conditions. The joints between the two lines shall be staggered to the extent possible.

4. When it is impossible to obtain the proper horizontal and vertical separation as stipulated above, both the water and sewer line shall be constructed in accordance with the requirements of R309-112.2.

1.14 ESTIMATES OF WASTEWATER QUANTITY: The maximum daily wastewater flow to be disposed of should be determined as accurately as possible, preferably by actual measurement. Where this is not possible, Table 5-2 may be used to estimate the flow.

 

TABLE 5-2
ESTIMATED QUANTITY OF DOMESTIC WASTEWATER

  

  TYPE OF ESTABLISHMENT                     GALLONS PER DAY

Construction/work camps (semi-permanent)  60 per person
  Resort camps with limited plumbing      60 per person
Country Clubs                             25 per person
Dwellings
  a.  Boarding house                      60 per person
      Additional kitchen waste for
        non-resident boarder              10 per person
  b.  Boarding schools                    75-100 per person
  c.  Condominium                         400 per unit
  d.  Mobile home                         400 per unit
  e.  Single family dwelling              400 per day
  f.  Rooming House                       40 per person
Highway Rest Areas (improved with
  restroom facilities)                    5 per vehicle
Hospitals                                 250 per bed
Nursing Homes                             200 per Bed
Institutions other than Hospitals
  and Nursing Homes                       75-125 per person
Motels and Hotels                         62 per person
Industrial Buildings (exclusive of
  industrial waste)                       15-35 per person
Launderette (self-service)                50 per load
Office Buildings
  a.  With cafeteria                      25 per employee
  b.  Without cafeteria                   15 per employee
Recreational Vehicle Parks/
  Campgrounds
  a.  Sanitary stations for
      self-contained Vehicles             50 per space
  b.  Independent spaces (temporary
      or transient with sewer
      connections)                        125 per space
  c.  Dependent spaces (temporary
      or transient with no sewer
      connections)                        125 per space
      with service building
      including showers                   35 per person
                                          (Campground)
      (1)  with service building
           but no showers                 85 per space
                                          25 per person
                                          (Campground)
  d.  Campground with no flush
      toilets                             5 per person
Restaurants                               35 per seat
  a.  Additional for bars and
      cocktail lounges                    2 per person
Schools
  a.  Boarding                            75 per person
  b.  Day, without cafeteria,
      gymnasiums or showers               15 per person
  c.  Day, with cafeteria, but
      no gymnasium or shower              20 per person
  d.  Day, with cafeteria, gymnasium
      and shower                          25 per person
Service Station (per vehicle served)      5 per vehicle
Ski Areas and Visitor Centers             5 per visitor

 

R317-5-2. Septic Tanks.

2.1 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS: Septic tanks shall be constructed of durable materials designed to withstand expected physical loads and corrosive forces. They shall be watertight and designed to provide settling of solids, accumulation of sludge and scum, and access for cleaning, as specified in the following paragraphs.

2.2 TANK CAPACITY: Septic tanks shall be sized on the following basis:

(1) V = 1.5Q for Q less than or equal to 1500

(2) V = 1125 + 0.75 Q for Q greater than 1500

V = liquid volume of tank in gallons

Q = (Maximum anticipated) wastewater discharge in gallons per day

2.3 TANK DIMENSIONS: In general, tank length should be at least 2 or 3 times the width. Liquid depth of tanks shall be at least 30 inches. A liquid depth greater than 6 feet shall not be considered in determining tank capacity.

2.4 TANK COMPARTMENTS: Septic tanks may be divided into compartments, or separate tanks may be installed in series, up to a maximum of 3, provided the following requirements are met:

A. The volume of the first compartment or tank must equal or exceed the volume of any other compartment.

B. No compartment or tank shall have an inside horizontal dimension less than 24 inches.

C. Inlets and outlets shall be designed as specified for tanks, except when a partition wall is used to form a multi-compartment tank. Under such conditions, an opening in the partition may be used to allow for flow between compartments, provided the minimum dimension of the opening is 4 inches, the cross-sectional area is not less than 30 square inches, and the mid-point is below the liquid surface a distance approximately equal to 40% of the liquid depth of the tank.

2.5 INLETS AND OUTLETS:

A. Inlets and outlets of tanks or compartments shall be submerged or baffled to divert incoming flow toward the tank bottom and minimize the discharge of sludge or scum in the effluent.

B. Sanitary Tees may be used in lieu of baffled inlet or outlet structures.

C. All outlet baffles shall extend below the liquid surface a distance equal to approximately 40% of the liquid depth. Space between the baffle top and the underside of the tank cover shall be at least 1 inch.

D. Scum storage volume shall consist of 15% or more of the required liquid capacity of the tank and shall be provided in the space between liquid surface and top of inlet devices, which shall be set at least 1 inch below the underside of the tank cover.

E. Inlets and outlets shall allow free venting of tank gases back through the drainage system.

F. The inlet invert shall be at least 1 inch above outlet invert.

2.6 ACCESS TO TANK:

A. Access to inlet and outlet devices shall be provided through properly placed openings not less than 18 inches in minimum horizontal dimension.

B. The top of the tank shall be at least 6 inches below finished grade.

C. If the top of the tank is located more than 18 inches below finished grade, all access openings required by sub-section (1) above, shall be extended to within 18 inches of the finished grade.

2.7 ABANDONED SEPTIC TANKS: Septic tanks, cesspools and seepage pits which are no longer in use shall be completely pumped and filled with sand or soil.

2.8 DISCHARGE TO ABSORPTION SYSTEM: Septic tank effluent shall be conducted to the absorption system through a watertight sewer line meeting the requirements for wastewater drainage lines as contained in R317-5-1.13(A), (B), and (F). Tees, wyes, or other distributing devices may be used as needed. If a distribution box is used, it shall be of sufficient size to accommodate the necessary distribution line connections. Outlet inverts shall be at the same elevation and at least 1 inch below the inlet invert. Conveyance to the absorption system must be adequately sized to handle peak hydraulic flow.

 

R317-5-3. Absorption Systems.

3.1 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS:

A. Suitable soil exploration, to a depth of about 10 feet, or at least 4 feet below the bottom of the proposed absorption systems and percolation tests, shall be made to provide information on subsoil conditions. Percolation tests and soil exploration reports shall be completed and submitted as part of the engineering report for the disposal facility. After January 1, 2002, the soil evaluation and percolation tests must be done in accordance with certification requirements in R317-11. A minimum of 5 percolation tests must be conducted at different sites for each disposal system. Additional tests may be required, where necessary to adequately evaluate the total absorption system or where there is significant variability in test results. In general, the system will be sized based on the slowest stabilized percolation test rate. Soil logs should be prepared in accordance with the Unified Soil Classification System by a qualified individual. Requirements outlined in R317-5-4.1 and Table 5-8 will be helpful in developing this information.

B. Absorption devices, including seepage pits or trenches, placed in sloping ground should be so constructed that the horizontal distance between the distribution line and the ground surface is at least 10 feet.

C. Soil having excessively high permeability, such as gravel with large voids, affords little filtering and is unsuitable for absorption systems. Percolation rates (R317-5-4.1) of approximately 5 minutes per inch or less usually will not be acceptable.

The extremely fine-grained "blow sand" found in some parts of Utah is generally unsuitable for absorption systems and should be avoided. If no choice is available, systems may be constructed in such material, provided it is within the required percolation range specified in this code, and the required area is calculated on the minimum percolation rate (60 minutes per inch for absorption fields and 30 minutes per inch for absorption beds).

D. Absorption system excavations may be made by machinery provided that the soil in the bottom and sides of the excavation is not compacted. Strict attention shall be given to the protection of the natural absorption properties of the soil. Absorption systems shall not be excavated when the soil is wet enough to smear or compact easily. All smeared or compacted surfaces should be raked to a depth of one inch, and loose material removed before the filter material is placed in the absorption system excavation.

E. Effluent distribution lines or pipe shall be perforated and should consist of 4-inch diameter pipe of appropriate material which has demonstrated satisfactory results for the given application. The distribution pipe shall be bedded true to line and grade, uniformly and continuously supported on firm, stable material.

F. The coarse material in the absorption system shall consist of crushed stone, gravel, or similar material of equivalent strength and durability. It shall be free from fines, dust, sand or clay. The top of the stone or gravel shall be covered with a pervious material such as an acceptable synthetic filter fabric, a 2-inch compacted layer of straw, or similar material before being covered with earth backfill to prevent infiltration of backfill into the stone or gravel.

G. Distribution pipes placed under driveways or other areas subjected to heavy loads shall receive special design considerations to insure against crushing or disruption of alignment. Absorption area under driveways or pavement shall not be considered in determining the minimum required absorption area.

H. Absorption systems shall be backfilled with earth that is free from debris and large rocks. The first 4 to 6 inches of soil backfill should be hand placed. Distribution pipes shall not be crushed or misaligned during backfilling. When backfilling, the earth should be mounded slightly above the surface of the ground to allow for settlement.

I. Heavy equipment shall not be driven in or over absorption systems during backfilling or after completion.

J. That portion of absorption system below the top of distribution pipes shall be in natural soil. Under unusual circumstances the Director may allow installation in acceptably stabilized earth fill. The earth fill and location will have to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, taking into consideration the soil characteristics and degree of consolidation of the fill material.

K. Soil and Ground Water Requirements. In areas where absorption systems are to be constructed, soil cover must be adequate to insure at least 4 feet of soil between bedrock or any other impervious formation, and the bottom of absorption systems. Maximum ground water elevation must be at least 2 feet below the bottom of absorption systems and at least 4 feet below finished grade.

L. Replacement Area for Absorption System. Adequate and suitable land shall be reserved and kept free of permanent structures, traffic, or adverse soil modification for replacement of the absorption system. Suitability must be demonstrated through soil exploration and percolation tests results.

3.2 ABSORPTION FIELDS: Absorption fields are the preferred type of absorption system. They consist of a series of gravel-filled trenches provided with perforated pipes designed to distribute septic tank effluent into the gravel fill, from which it percolates through the trench walls and bottom into the surrounding sub-surface soil.

A. Design of absorption fields shall be as outlined in Tables 5-3 and 5-4.

 

TABLE 5-3
ABSORPTION FIELD CONSTRUCTION DETAILS

  

       ITEMS                           UNITS        MINIMUM  MAXIMUM

     Number of lateral trenches                   2        -
     Length of trenches              Feet         -        100
     Width of trenches               Inches       12       36
     Slope of pipe (bottom)          In./100 ft.  Level    Level
     Depth of coarse material:
       Under pipe                    Inches       6        -
       Under pipe located within
         10 ft. of trees             Inches       12       -
       Over pipe                     Inches       2        -
     Size of coarse material         Inches       3/4      2-1/2
     Depth of backfill over
       coarse material               Inches       6        -

 

 

TABLE 5-4
SIZE AND MINIMUM SPACING FOR ABSORPTION FIELD TRENCHES

  

       Minimum Spacing of      wall to
     Trenches Width of       wall (ft.)
     trench at bottom
     (inches)

     12 to 18                6.0
     18 to 24                6.5
     24 to 30                7.0
     30 to 36                7.5

 

B. The minimum absorption area (total bottom area of trenches) of the absorption field shall be determined from the following equation but in no case the maximum allowable application rate shall exceed 2.2 gallons per square foot per day

Q = 5 / square root of t

Where Q = maximum rate of effluent application to the soil in gallons per square foot per day

t = stabilized percolation rate in minutes per inch

Percolation tests shall be performed as specified in R317-5-4.1. Rates in excess of 60 minutes per inch indicate a soil unsuitable for absorption field construction.

C. Wherever possible all trench bottoms should be constructed at the same elevation. Distribution pipes and trenches should be level and should be connected at both ends to provide a continuous system. If ground surface slope is too steep to permit a level installation, then a system of serial trenches following land contours should be used, with each trench and distribution pipe being constructed level but at a different elevation. A schematic diagram showing the recommended layout of trenches and distribution systems is available from the Director.

1. The system should include drop boxes which should generally conform to the detail in Appendix 1 and should operate in such a manner that a trench will be filled with wastewater to the depth of the gravel fill before the wastewater flows to the next lower trench. The drop boxes shall be watertight and should be provided with a means of access at the top.

2. The lines between the drop boxes should be a minimum of 4 inches in diameter and should be watertight with direct connections to the distribution box. They should be laid in a trench excavated through undisturbed earth to the exact depth required. Backfill should be carefully tamped.

3.3 ABSORPTION BEDS: Absorption beds consist of large excavated areas provided with gravel fill in which effluent distribution lines are laid. They may be used in place of absorption fields when trenches are not considered desirable, and shall conform to requirements applying to absorption fields, except for the following:

A. They shall comply with construction details specified in Table 5-5.

 

TABLE 5-5
ABSORPTION BED CONSTRUCTION DETAILS

  

       ITEM                        UNIT      MINIMUM   MAXIMUM

     Distance between
     distribution lines          Feet      -         6

     Distance between
     distribution lines
     and wall                    Feet      -         3

     Depth to bottom of bed      Feet      1-1/2     -

     Size of coarse material     Inches    3/4       2-1/2

     Depth of coarse material
       Under pipe                Inches    6         -
       In bed within 10 ft.
         of trees                Inches    12        -
       Over pipe                 Inches    2         -

     Depth of backfill over
     coarse material             Inches    6         -

 

B. Required absorption area (total bottom area of bed) shall be determined from the following equation, but in no case shall it exceed 1.1 gallons per square foot per day.

Q = 2.5/square root of t

Where Q = maximum rate of effluent application to the soil in gallons per square foot per day.

t = stabilized percolation rate in minutes per inch.

Percolation tests shall be performed as specified in R317-5-4.1. Rates in excess of 30 minutes per inch indicate a soil unsuitable for absorption bed construction.

3.3 SEEPAGE PITS: If absorption fields or beds are not feasible, seepage pits will be considered. These consist of deep pits which receive septic tank effluent and allow it to seep through sidewalls into the adjacent subsurface soil. Seepage pits may be either hollow lined or filled with clean coarse material. They shall conform to the following requirements:

A. Number and size of seepage pits required shall be determined by calculation of seepage rate into each stratum of soil encountered in pit sidewall by reference to Table 5-8. Only pervious side-wall area below the inlet shall be considered. In order to calculate a sidewall seepage rate a representative number of soil explorations shall be evaluated to adequately identify the type and depth of each soil stratum expected throughout the absorption area. In general, a minimum of 5 explorations will be evaluated. This information shall be provided in the engineering report.

B. For the purposes of confirming an appropriate sidewall seepage rate, the owner shall submit a statement describing the character and thickness of each stratum of soil encountered during pit construction. Soil classification and assumed seepage rates shall be as specified in Table 5-8 except when valid seepage measurements are available.

C. The lining may be brick, stone, block or similar materials, at least 4 inches thick, laid in cement mortar above the inlet and with tight butted joints below the inlet. The annular space between the lining and the earth wall shall be filled with crushed rock or gravel varying in diameter from 3/4 inch to 2-1/2 inches.

D. A structurally sound and otherwise suitable top shall be provided. Structural design and materials used throughout shall assure a durable safe structure.

E. If more than one seepage pit is provided, the installation may be operated in series or parallel with distribution of effluent as specified in R317-5-2.1(G).

F. For hollow lined pits, the inlet pipe should extend horizontally at least 1 foot into the pit with a tee to divert flow downward and prevent washing and eroding the sidewall.

G. For filled pits a thin layer of crushed rock or gravel ranging from 3/4 to 2-1/2 inches in diameter, free from fines, sand, clay or organic material shall cover the coarse material to permit leveling of the distribution pipe.

 

TABLE 5-6
SEEPAGE PITS CONSTRUCTION DETAILS

 

       ITEM                         UNIT      MINIMUM   MAXIMUM
       Generals
         Distance between
           seepage pits             feet      12(a)     -
         Diameter of
           distribution pipe        inches    4         -
         Size of coarse
           material                 inches    3/4       12
         Bottom of pit to
           maximum ground
           water                    feet      2         -
         Bottom of Pit in
           unsuitable soil
           or bedrock
           formations               feet      4         -
       Hollow-lined Pits:
         Width of annular
           space between
           lining and sidewall
           containing crushed
           rock (3/4 to 2-1/2
           inches in diameter)      inches    6         -
         Thickness of brick,
           or block linings         inches    4(b)
       Filled Pits:
         Depth of coarse material:
         Under pipe                 feet      4         -
         Over distribution pipe     inches    2         -
         Depth of backfill over
           material                 inches    6         -

       Footnotes:
       (a)  See Table 5-1
       (b)  Pre-manufactured linings may be approved with
  thicknesses less than 4 inches.

 

3.5 SEEPAGE TRENCHES (MODIFIED SEEPAGE PITS): Seepage trenches are considered as modified seepage pits and consist of deep trenches filled with clean, coarse material. They shall conform to the requirements applying to seepage pits except for the following:

A. The effective sidewall absorption area shall be considered as the outside surface of the seepage trench (vertical sidewall area) calculated below the inlet or distribution pipe. Only pervious sidewall area below the inlet shall be considered.

 

TABLE 5-7
SEEPAGE TRENCH DETAIL

  

    ITEM                                UNIT      MINIMUM   MAXIMUM

  Seepage trench width                feet      2         -
  Seepage trench length               feet      -         100
  Effluent Distribution pipe
    Diameter                          inches    4         -
    Slope                             percent   level     level
  Distance between seepage trenches   feet      12(a)     -

     Footnote:
     (a)  See Table 5-1.

 

 

TABLE 5-8
SEEPAGE TRENCHES AND PITS
ALLOWABLE SIDEWALL SEEPAGE RATES

  

              SYMBOL AND CHARACTER OF SOIL         GALLONS/
            BY UNIFIED SOIL CLASSIFICATION       DAY/
            SYSTEM                               SQ. FT.

            Hardpan or bedrock (including
            fractured bedrock with little
            or no fines).                        0

     GW     Well graded gravels,
            gravel-sand mixtures little
            or no fines.                         1.55

     GP     Poorly graded gravels or
            gravel-sand mixtures, little
            or no fines.                         1.55

     SW     Well graded sands, gravelly
            sand, little or no fines.            1.20

     SP     Poorly graded sands or gravelly
            sands, little or no fines.           1.20

     SM     Silty sand, sand-silt mixtures.      0.8

     GM     Silty gravels, poorly graded
            gravel-sand-silt mixtures.           1.0

     GC     Clayey gravels,
            gravelly-sand-clay mixtures.          0.45(a)

     SC     Clayey sands, sand-clay
            mixtures.                            0.45(a)

     ML     Inorganic silts and very fine
            sand, rock flour, silt or
            clayey find sands or clayey
            silts with slight plasticity.        0.45(a)

     MH     Inorganic silts, micaceous
            or diatomaceous fine sandy
            or silty soils, elastic silts.       0.45(a)(b)

     CL     Inorganic clays or low to
            medium plasticity, gravelly
            clays, sandy clays, silty
            clays, lean clays.                   0.45(a)(b)

     CH     Inorganic clays of high
            plasticity, fat clays.               0

     OL     Organic silts and organic
            silty clays of low plasticity.       0

     OH     Organic clays of medium to
            high plasticity, organic silts.      0

     PT     Peat and other highly organic
            silts.                               0

     Other  Impervious formations.               0

     Footnotes:
     (a)  For the purpose of this table, whenever there are
reasonable doubts regarding the suitability and estimated
absorption capacities of soils, percolation tests shall be
conducted in those soils in accordance with R317-4-1.  Soils
within the same classification may exhibit extreme variability in
permeability, depending on the amount and type of clay and silt
present.  The following soils categories, SC,GC, and ML, MH and CL
soils, may prove unsatisfactory for absorption systems, depending
upon the percentage and type of fines present.
     (b)  These soils are usually considered unsuitable for
absorption systems, but may be suitable, depending upon the
percentage and type of fines in coarse-grained porous soils, and
the percentage of sand and gravels in fine-grained soils.

 

R317-5-4. Percolation Tests.

A. General Requirements.

1. A percolation test measures the rate which subsurface soil absorbs water for the purpose of identifying porous soil strata and site suitability for absorption systems, and is also a basis for estimating the design criteria of such systems to insure a reasonably long lifespan.

2. While percolation tests constitute a valuable guide for successful operation of disposal systems, considerable judgment must be used in applying the results. Percolation test results shall not be presumptive, prima facie, or conclusive evidence as to the suitability for absorption systems. Such percolation tests may be considered and analyzed as one of many criteria in determining soil suitability for absorption systems. There is no need for conducting percolation tests when the soil or other site conditions are clearly unsuitable.

3. When percolation tests are made, such tests shall be made at points and elevations selected as typical of the area in which the absorption system will be located. Consideration should be given to the finished grades of building sites so that test results will represent the percolation rate of the soil in which absorption systems will be constructed. After the suitability of any area to be used for absorption systems has been evaluated and approved for construction, no grade changes shall be made to this area unless the health authority is notified and a reevaluation of the area's suitability is made prior to the initiation of construction.

B. Required Test Procedures.

1. Test results when required shall be considered an essential part of plans for absorption systems and shall be submitted on a signed "Percolation Test Certificate" or equivalent, certifying that the tests were conducted in accordance with these requirements, and indicating the depth and rate of each test in minutes per inch, the date of the tests, the logs of the soil exploration pits, a statement of the present and maximum ground water table, and all other factors affecting percolation test results. Percolation tests shall be conducted at the owner's expense by or under the supervision of a registered sanitarian, registered engineer, or other qualified person approved by the health authority in accordance with the following:

(a) Conditions Prohibited for Test Holes.

Percolation tests shall not be conducted in test holes which extend into ground water, bedrock, or frozen ground. Where a fissured soil formation is encountered, tests shall be made under the direction of the health authority.

(b) Number and Location of Percolation Tests.

One or more tests shall be made in separate test holes on the proposed absorption system site to assure that the results are representative of the soil conditions present.

Where questionable or poor soil conditions exist, the number of percolation tests and soil explorations necessary to yield accurate, representative information shall be determined by the health authority and may be accepted only if conducted with an authorized representative present.

(c) Type, Depth, and Dimensions of Test Holes.

Test holes shall be dug or bored, preferably with hand tools such as shovels or augers, etc., and shall have horizontal dimensions ranging from 4 to 18 inches (preferably 8 to 12 inches). The vertical sides shall be at least 12 inches deep, terminating in the soil at an elevation 6 inches below the bottom of the proposed absorption system.

2. Test Procedure for Sandy or Granular Soils

For tests in sandy or granular soils containing little or no clay, the hole shall be carefully filled with clear water to a minimum depth of 12 inches over the gravel and the time for this amount of water to seep away shall be determined. The procedure shall be repeated and if the water from the second filling of the hole at least 12 inches above the gravel seeps away in 10 minutes, or less, the test may proceed immediately as follows:

(a) Water shall be added to a point not more than 6 inches above the gravel.

(b) Thereupon, from the fixed reference point, water levels shall be measured at 10 minute intervals for a period of 1 hour.

(c) If 6 inches of water seeps away in less than 10 minutes a shorter time interval between measurements shall be used, but in no case shall the water depth exceed 6 inches.

(d) The final water level drop shall be used to calculate the percolation rate.

3. Test Procedure for Other Soils Not Meeting the Above Requirements.

The hole shall be carefully filled with clear water and a minimum depth of 12 inches shall be maintained above the gravel for at least a 4-hour period by refilling whenever necessary. Water remaining in the hole after 4 hours shall not be removed. Immediately following the saturation period, the soil shall be allowed to swell not less than 16 hours or more than 30 hours. Immediately following the soil swelling period, the percolation rate measurements shall be made as follows:

(a) Any soil which has sloughed into the hole shall be removed and water shall be adjusted to 6 inches over the gravel.

(b) Thereupon, from the fixed reference point, the water level shall be measured and recorded at approximately 30 minute intervals for a period of 4 hours unless 2 successive water level drops do not vary more than 1/16 of an inch and indicate that an approximate stabilized rate has been obtained.

(c) The hole shall be filled with clear water to a point not more than 6 inches above the gravel whenever it becomes nearly empty.

(d) Adjustments of the water level shall not be made during the last 3 measurement periods except to the limits of the last water level drop.

(e) When the first 6 inches of water seeps away in less than 30 minutes, the time interval between measurements shall be 10 minutes, and the test run for 1 hour.

(f) The water depth shall not exceed 6 inches at any time during the measurement period.

(g) The drop that occurs during the final measurement period shall be used in calculating the percolation rate.

4. Calculation of Percolation Rate.

The percolation rate is equal to the time elapsed in minutes for the water column to drop, divided by the distance the water dropped in inches or fractions thereof.

5. Using Percolation Rate to Determine Absorption Area.

The minimum or slowest percolation rate shall be used in calculating the required absorption area.

C. Recommendations to Enhance Test Procedures.

1. Soil Exploration Pit Prerequisite to Percolation Tests.

Since the appropriate percolation test depth depends on the soil conditions at a specific site, the percolation test should be conducted only after the soil exploration pit has been dug and examined for suitable and porous strata and ground water table information. Percolation test results should be related to the soil conditions found.

2. Test Holes to Commence in Specially Prepared Excavations.

All percolation test holes should commence in specially prepared larger excavations (preferably made with a backhoe) of sufficient size which extend to a depth approximately 6 inches above the strata to be tested.

3. Preparation of Percolation Test Hole. Carefully roughen or scratch the bottom and sides of the hole with a knife blade or other sharp pointed instrument in order to remove any smeared soil surfaces and to provide an open, natural soil interface into which water may percolate. Nails driven into a board will provide a good instrument to scarify the sides of the hole. Remove all loose soil from the bottom of the hole. Add up to 3 inches of clean coarse sand or pea-sized gravel to protect the bottom from scouring or sealing with sediment when water is added.

Caving or sloughing in some test holes can be prevented by placing in the test hole a wire cylinder or perforated pipe surrounded by clean coarse gravel.

4. Saturation and Swelling of the Soil. It is important to distinguish between saturation and swelling. Saturation means that the void spaces between soil particles are full of water. This can be accomplished in a relatively short period of time. Swelling is a soil volume increase caused by increase intrusion of water into the individual soil particles. This is a slow process, especially in clay-type soil, and is the reason for requiring a prolonged swelling period.

5. Placing Water in Test Holes.

Water should be placed carefully into the test holes by means of a small-diameter siphon hose or other suitable method to prevent washing down the side of the hole.

6. Percolation Rate Measurement, General.

Necessary equipment should consist of a tape measure (with at least 1/16-inch calibration) or float gauge and a time piece or other suitable equipment. All measurements shall be made from a fixed reference point near the top of the test hole to the surface of the water.

]R317-5. Large Underground Wastewater Disposal (LUWD) Systems.

R317-5-1. Authority, Purpose, Scope, Jurisdiction, Waiver Approval and Administrative Requirements.

1.1. Authority.

Construction and operating permits and approvals are issued pursuant to the provisions of Utah Water Quality Act Sections 19-5-104, 19-5-106, 19-5-107 and 19-5-108. Violation of these permits or approvals including compliance with the conditions thereof, or beginning construction, or modification without the director's approval, is subject to the penalties provided in Section 19-5-115.

1.2. Purpose.

A. The purpose of this rule is to protect the public health and the environment from potential adverse effects from large underground wastewater disposal systems within the boundaries of Utah.

B. This rule incorporates specific provisions contained in Rule R317-4 that are referenced herein, and pertinent to large underground wastewater disposal (LUWD) systems for the purpose of providing minimum design standards. Where the engineered design includes information supporting a deviation from the minimum requirements within this rule or referenced to in Rule R317-4, then the engineer may request a waiver. This rule also establishes the administrative requirements for obtaining from the division a LUWD system:

1. approval-in-concept;

2. construction permit;

3. authorization to use; and

4. operating permit

1.3 Scope.

This rule applies to large underground wastewater disposal systems designed to handle more than 5,000 gallons per day of domestic wastewater, or wastewater that originates in multiple units under separate ownership (except condominiums), or any other underground wastewater disposal system not covered under the definition of an onsite wastewater system per Rule R317-4.

A. The engineer shall use recognized practice standards for wastewater treatment to increase long term performance and lessen potential impacts to public health and the environment. Depending on site-specific characteristics, the division may require a LUWD system to pretreat effluent prior to disposal in the absorption system. In general, systems with high waste strength or flows over 15,000 gpd should consider pretreatment. Factors that should be evaluated include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. design flow (gpd)

2. highly variable flows, including seasonal fluctuations;

3. wastewater strength characteristics;

4. site characteristics.

5. proximity to ground water table, considering various soil types and separation distance;

6. ground water classification;

7. proximity to nearby drinking water sources, or location within a drinking water source protection zone; and

8. anticipated system life expectancy.

1.4. Jurisdiction. Large underground wastewater disposal systems are under the jurisdiction of the Division of Water Quality. Local Health Departments may petition the division to require local review for compliance with local requirements prior to the division initiating its review.

1.5 Waiver.

The director may grant a waiver from the minimum requirements stated in this rule, subject to site-specific consideration and justification, but not overriding the safeguarding of public health, protection of water quality or engineering practice. The intent of the waiver is to allow the engineer to utilize site specific information, recognized practice standards, or other acceptable justification while designing an appropriate LUWD system for the property. The engineer is encouraged to discuss waivers with the division staff prior to formal application for feasibility determination review.

 

R317-5-2. Definitions.

2.1. Definitions found in Rules R317-1 and R317-4 apply to large underground wastewater disposal systems except where specifically replaced by the following definitions:

"Alternative system" means a LUWD system that is not a conventional system.

"Building sewer" means the pipe that carries wastewater from the building to a public sewer, a LUWD system, or other point of dispersal. It sometimes is synonymous with "house sewer".

"Conventional system" means a LUWD system typically consisting of a building sewer, septic tank, and an absorption system utilizing absorption trenches, absorption beds, or deep wall trenches.

"Curtain drain" means any ground water interceptor or drainage system that is backfilled with gravel or other suitable material and is intended to interrupt or divert the course of shallow ground water or surface water away from the LUWD system.

"Malfunctioning or failing system" means a LUWD system that is not functioning in compliance with the requirements of this rule and may include:

1. absorption systems that seep or flow to the surface of the ground or into waters of the state;

2. systems that overflow from any of their components;

3. systems that cause backflow into any portion of a building drainage system;

4. systems discharging effluent that does not comply with applicable effluent discharge standards of its operating permit;

5. leaking septic tanks; or

6. noncompliance with standards stipulated in or by the construction permit, operating permit, or both.

"Maximum ground water table" means the highest elevation that the top of the "ground water table" or "ground water table, perched" is expected to reach for any reason over the full operating life of a LUWD system at that site.

"Mound system" means an alternative LUWD system where the bottom of the absorption system is placed above the elevation of the original site, and the absorption system is contained in a mounded fill body above that grade.

"Packed bed media system" means an alternative LUWD system that uses natural or synthetic media to treat wastewater. Biological treatment is facilitated via microbial growth on the surface of the media. The system may include a pump tank, a recirculation tank, or both.

"Public health hazard" means, for the purpose of this rule, a condition whereby there are sufficient types and amounts of biological, chemical, or physical agents relating to water or sewage that are likely to cause human illness, disorders or disability. These may include pathogenic viruses and bacteria, parasites, toxic chemicals and radioactive isotopes. A malfunctioning LUWD system constitutes a public health hazard.

"Sand lined trench system" means an alternative LUWD system consisting of a series of narrow excavated trenches utilizing sand media and pressure distribution.

"Unapproved LUWD system" means any LUWD system that is deemed by the division to be any of the following:

1. installation without the required division oversight, permits, or inspections;

2. repairs to an existing system without the required division oversight, permits, or inspections; or

3. alteration to an existing system without the required division oversight, permits, or inspections.

"Waiver" means an acceptable deviation from the requirements established within this rule or referenced rules. The waiver must be acceptable to division staff based on the engineer providing adequate design justification to demonstrate that the deviation proposed will not override the safeguarding of public health, the protection of water quality, or the protection of the receiving environment. Waiver requests should be based on acceptable engineering practice and standards.

 

R317-5-3. General Standards, Prohibitions, Requirements, and Enforcement.

3.1. Failure to Comply With Rules.

Any person failing to comply with this rule shall be subject to enforcement action as specified in Sections 19-5-115 and 26A-1-123.

3.2. Feasibility.

LUWD systems are not feasible in some areas and situations. If property characteristics indicate conditions that may fail in any way to meet the requirements specified herein, the use of a LUWD system shall be prohibited.

3.3. Prohibited Flows.

No ground water drainage, drainage from roofs, roads, yards, or other similar sources shall discharge into any portion of a LUWD system, but shall be disposed of so they will in no way affect the system. Non-domestic wastes such as chemicals, paints, or other substances that are detrimental to the proper functioning of a LUWD system may not be disposed of in such systems.

3.4. Increased Flows Prohibited.

Wastewater flow may not exceed the design flow of a LUWD system.

3.5. Property Lines Crossed.

Privately owned LUWD systems, including replacement areas, shall be located on the same lot as the building served unless, when approved by the division, a perpetual utility easement and right-of-way is established and recorded on an adjacent or nearby lot for the construction, operation, and continued maintenance, repair, alteration, inspection, relocation, and replacement of a LUWD system, including all rights to ingress and egress necessary or convenient for the full or complete use, occupation, and enjoyment of the granted easement. The easement shall be large enough to accommodate the proposed LUWD system and replacement area. The easement shall meet the setbacks specified in Section R317-4-13 Table 2.

3.6. Initial Absorption Area and Replacement Area.

A. All properties that utilize LUWD systems shall be required to have a replacement area.

B. The absorption area, including installed system and replacement area, may not be subject to activity that is likely to adversely affect the soil or the functioning of the system. This may include vehicular traffic, covering the area with asphalt, concrete, or structures, filling, cutting or other soil modifications.

3.7. Operation and Maintenance.

Owners of a LUWD systems shall operate, maintain, and service their systems according to the standards of this rule.

3.8. No Discharge to Surface Waters or Ground Surface.

Effluent from any LUWD system may not be discharged to surface waters or upon the surface of the ground. Wastewater may not be discharged into any abandoned or unused well, or into any crevice, sinkhole, or similar opening, either natural or artificial.

3.9. Repair of a Malfunctioning or Unapproved System.

Upon determination by the regulatory authority that a malfunctioning or unapproved LUWD wastewater system creates or contributes to any dangerous or unsanitary condition that may involve a public health hazard, or noncompliance with this rule, the regulatory authority shall order the owner to take the necessary action to cause the condition to be corrected, eliminated or otherwise come into compliance.

A. For malfunctioning systems, the regulatory authority shall require and order:

1. all necessary steps, such as maintenance, servicing, repairs, and replacement of system components to correct the malfunctioning system, to meet all rule requirements to the extent possible and may not create any new risk to the environment or public health;

2. effluent quality testing as required by Subsection R317-5-9.2.D;

3. evaluation of the system design including non-approved changes to the system, the wastewater flow, and biological and chemical loading to the system;

4. additional tests or samples to troubleshoot the system malfunction.

3.10. Procedure for Wastewater System Abandonment. Whenever the use of a LUWD system has been abandoned or discontinued, the owner of the real property on which such wastewater system is located shall render it safe by having the septic tank, any other tanks, hollow seepage pit, or cesspool wastes pumped out or otherwise disposed of in an approved manner. Within 30 days the tanks shall be:

A. crushed in place and the void filled;

B. completely filled with earth, sand, or gravel; or

C. removed and backfilled.

3.11. Septage Management.

A person shall only dispose of septage, or sewage contaminated materials in a location or manner in accordance with the requirements of the division and any local agencies having jurisdiction.

3.12. Multiple Units Under Separate Ownership (except condominiums).

The common components of the LUWD system, including the reserve absorption area, shall be under the sponsorship of a body politic.

A. The subsurface absorption system shall be designed and constructed to provide duplicate capacity, meaning two independent systems. Each system shall be designed to accommodate the total anticipated maximum daily flow. The duplicate system shall be designed with appropriate valving, etc., to allow for periodic alternation of the use of each system.

B. Sufficient land area with suitable characteristics shall be planned and available to provide for a third absorption system capable of handling the total maximum daily wastewater flow. This area shall be kept free of permanent structures, traffic or soil modification.

3.13. Underground Injection Control.

Large underground wastewater disposal (LUWD) systems with design flow rates of 5,000 gallons per day or more are co-regulated by the Utah 1422 Underground Injection Control (UIC) Program in Rule R317-7. LUWD systems are authorized-by-rule under the UIC program provided they remain in compliance with the construction and operating permits issued according to Rule R317-5. However, if any noncompliance with these permits results in the potential for or demonstration of actual exceedance of any Utah Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) in a receiving ground water, the noncompliance may also be a violation of the Utah UIC administrative rules and therefore be subject to enforcement action. Owners and operators of a large underground wastewater disposal system are required to submit UIC inventory information according to Subsection R317-7-6.4(C) using the approved form for a LUWD system.

 

R317-5-4. Feasibility Determination and Approval-in-Concept.

4.1. General Criteria for Determining LUWD System Feasibility.

The division shall determine the feasibility of using a LUWD system. Upon favorable determination for feasibility an approval-in-concept will be granted by the division.

A. General Information. The required information shall include:

1. situs address if available;

2. name and address of the property owner and person requesting feasibility;

3. the location, type, and depth of all existing and proposed private and public drinking water wells, and other water supply sources within 1500 feet of the proposed LUWD system;

4. the location of all drinking water source protection zones delineated on the project site;

5. the location of all existing creeks, drainages, irrigation ditches, canals, and other surface and subsurface water conveyances within 1500 feet of the proposed LUWD system;

6. the location and distance to nearest sewer, owner of sewer, whether property is located within service boundary, and size of sewer; and

7. statement of proposed use if other than a single-family dwelling.

B. If the proposed LUWD system is located in aquifer recharge areas or areas of other particular geologic concern, the division may require such additional information relative to ground water movement, or possible subsurface wastewater flow.

C. Soil and Site Evaluation.

1. Soil Exploration Pit and Percolation Test.

a. A minimum of five soil exploration pits shall be excavated to allow the evaluation of the soils. The soil exploration pits shall be constructed and soil logs recorded as detailed in Section R317-4-14 Appendix C.

b. The division may require percolation tests in addition to the soil exploration pits.

c. The division may require additional pits, tests, or both where:

i. soil structure varies;

ii. limiting geologic conditions are encountered; or

iii. the division deems it necessary.

d. The percolation test shall be conducted as detailed in Section R317-4-14 Appendix D.

e. Soil exploration pits and percolation tests shall be conducted as closely as possible to the proposed absorption system site. The division shall have the option of inspecting the open soil exploration pits and monitoring the percolation test procedure. All soil logs and percolation test results shall be submitted to the division.

f. When there is a substantial discrepancy between the percolation rate and the soil classification, it shall be resolved through additional soil exploration pits, percolation tests, or both.

g. Absorption system feasibility and sizing shall be based on Section R317-4-13 Table 5 or 6.

2. Wind-Blown Sand.

The extremely fine grained wind-blown sand found in some parts of Utah shall be deemed not feasible for LUWD systems unless pretreatment is provided, as percolation test results in wind-blown sand will generally be rapid, but experience has shown that this soil has a tendency to become sealed with minute organic particles within a short period of time.

3. Suitable Soil Depth.

For conventional systems, effective suitable soil depth shall extend at least 48 inches or more below the bottom of the dispersal system to bedrock formations, impervious strata, or excessively permeable soil. Some alternative LUWD systems may have other requirements.

4. Ground Water Requirements.

The elevation of the anticipated maximum ground water table shall meet the separation requirements of the anticipated absorption systems.

a. Maximum Ground Water.

Maximum ground water table shall be determined where the anticipated maximum ground water table, including irrigation induced water table, might be expected to rise closer than 48 inches to the elevation of the bottom of a LUWD system. Maximum ground water table shall be determined where alternative LUWD wastewater systems may be considered based on groundwater elevations. The maximum ground water table shall be determined by the following.

i. Regular monitoring of the ground water table, or ground water table, perched, in an observation well for a period of one year, or for the period of the maximum groundwater table.

(1) Previous ground water records and climatological or other information may be consulted for each site proposed for a LUWDS system and may be used to adjust the observed maximum ground water table elevation.

ii. Direct visual observation of the maximum ground water table in a soil exploration pit for:

(1) evidence of crystals of salt left by the maximum ground water table; or

(2) chemically reduced iron in the soil, reflected by redoximorphoric features i.e., a mottled coloring.

(3) Previous ground water records and climatological or other information may be consulted for each site proposed for a LUWD system and may be used to adjust the observed maximum ground water table elevation in determining the anticipated maximum ground water table elevation.

iii. In cases where the anticipated maximum ground water table is expected to rise to closer than 34 inches from the original ground surface and an alternative LUWD system would be considered, previous ground water records and climatological or other information shall be used to adjust the observed maximum ground water table in determining the anticipated maximum ground water table.

b. Curtain Drains.

A curtain drain or other effective ground water interceptor may be allowed as an attempt to lower the groundwater table to meet the requirements of this rule. The division shall require that the effectiveness of such devices in lowering the ground water table be demonstrated during the season of maximum ground water table.

5. Ground Slope.

Absorption systems may not be placed on slopes where the addition of fluids is judged to create an unstable slope.

a. Absorption systems may be placed on slopes between 0% and 25%, inclusive.

b. Absorption systems may be placed on slopes greater than 25% but not exceeding 35% if:

i. all other requirements of this rule can be met;

ii. effluent from the proposed system will not contaminate ground water or surface water, and will not surface or move off site before it is adequately treated to protect public health and the environment;

iii. no slope will fail, and there will be no other landslide or structural failure if the system is constructed and operated adequately, even if all properties in the vicinity are developed with a LUWD system; and

iv. a report is submitted by a professional engineer or professional geologist that is licensed to practice in Utah. The report shall be imprinted with the engineer's or geologist's registration seal and signature and shall include the following.

(1) Predictions and supporting information of ground water transport from the proposed system and of expected areas of ground water mounding.

(2) A slope stability analysis that shall include information about the geology of the site and surrounding area, soil exploration and testing, and the effects of adding effluent.

(3) The cumulative effect on slope stability of added effluent if all properties in the vicinity were developed with LUWD systems.

c. Absorption systems may not be placed on slopes greater than 35%.

6. Other Factors Affecting a LUWD System Feasibility.

a. The locations of all rivers, streams, creeks, dry or ephemeral washes, lakes, canals, marshes, subsurface drains, natural storm water drains, lagoons, artificial impoundments, either existing or proposed, that will affect building sites, shall be provided.

b. Areas proposed for LUWD wastewater systems shall comply with the setbacks in Section R317-4-13 Table 2.

c. If any part of a property lies within or abuts a flood plain area, the flood plain shall be shown within a contour line and shall be clearly labeled on the plan with the words "flood plain area".

7. Unsuitable.

Where soil and other site conditions are clearly unsuitable for the placement of a LUWD system, there is no need for conducting soil exploration pits or percolation tests.

 

R317-5-5. Engineering Reports, Plans and Construction Permits.

All engineering reports, plans and specifications shall be prepared by a registered professional engineer licensed to practice in the State of Utah and certified Level 3 in accordance with Rule R317-11.

5.1 Engineering Report.

An engineering report shall be submitted which shall contain design criteria along with all other information necessary to clearly describe the proposed project and demonstrate project feasibility as described in feasibility determination and approval-in-concept of Section R317-5-4.

5.2. Plan Review.

Submission of plans for review. Plans for new, alterations, repairs and replacements of large underground wastewater disposal systems shall be submitted to the division for review as required by Rule R317-1 and include the following:

A. Local Health Departments Requirements.

It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that a LUWD System application to the division is in compliance with local health department requirements regarding the location, design, construction and maintenance of a LUWD system prior to the applicant submitting a request for a construction permit to the division. Where the petition has been approved by the director, the applicant is required to submit documentation that the local health department has approved the proposed LUWD system before a construction permit may be issued.

B. Information Required.

Plans submitted for review shall be drawn to scale, 1" = 10', 20' or 30', or other scale as approved by the division. Plans shall be prepared in such a manner that the contractor can read and follow them in order to install the system properly. Depending on the individual site and circumstances, or as determined by the division, some or all of the following information may be required.

1. Applicant Information.

a. The name, current address, and telephone number of the applicant.

b. Complete address, legal description of the property, or both to be served by this LUWD system.

2. LUWD System Site Plan.

a. Submittal date of plan.

b. North arrow.

c. Lot size and dimensions.

d. Legal description of property.

e. Ground surface contours, preferably at 2 foot intervals, of both the original and proposed final grades of the property, or relative elevations using an established bench mark.

f. Location and explanation of type of dwelling(s) or structure(s) to be served by a LUWD system.

g. Location and dimensions of paved and unpaved driveways, roadways and parking areas.

h. Location and dimensions of the essential components of the wastewater system including the replacement area for the absorption system.

i. Location of all soil exploration pits and all percolation test holes.

j. Location of building sewer and water service line to serve the building.

k. Location of sewer mains, manholes, clean-outs, and other appurtenances.

l. Location of easements or drainage right-of-ways affecting the property.

m. Location of all intermittent or year-round streams, ditches, watercourses, ponds, subsurface drains, etc. within 100 feet of proposed LUWD system.

n. The location, type, and depth of all existing and proposed water supply sources

o. Delineation of all drinking water source protection zones located on the project site.

p. Distance to nearest public water main and size of main.

q. Distance to nearest public sewer, size of sewer, and whether accessible by gravity.

3. Statement with Site Plan.

Statement indicating the source of culinary water supply, whether a well, spring, non-public or public system, its location and distances from all LUWD systems.

4. Soil Evaluation.

a. Soil Logs, Percolation Test Certificates, or both.

b. Statement with supporting evidence indicating the maximum anticipated ground water table and the flooding potential for LUWD system sites.

5. Relative Elevations.

Show relative elevations of the following, using an established bench mark.

a. Building drain outlet.

b. The inlet and outlet inverts of any septic tanks.

c. Septic tank access cover, including height and diameter of riser, if used.

d. Pump tank inlet, if used, including height and diameter of riser.

e. The outlet invert of the distribution box, if provided, and the ends or corners of each distribution pipe lateral in the absorption system.

f. The final ground surface over the absorption system.

6. System Design.

Details for said site, plans, and specifications are listed in Design in Section R317-4-6.

a. Schedule or grade, material, diameter, and minimum slope of building sewer and effluent sewer.

b. Septic tank and pump tank capacity, design, cross sections, etc., materials, and dimensions. If tank is commercially manufactured, state the name and address of manufacturer.

c. Absorption system details, including the following:

i. details of drop boxes or distribution boxes, if provided;

ii. schedule or grade, material, and diameter of distribution pipes;

iii. length, slope, and spacing of each absorption system component;

iv. maximum slope across ground surface of absorption system area;

v. distance of absorption system from trees, cut banks, fills, or subsurface drains; and cross section of absorption system showing the:

(1) depth and width of absorption system excavation;

(2) depth of distribution pipe;

(3) depth of filter material;

(4) barrier material, i.e., synthetic filter fabric, straw, etc., used to separate filter material from cover; and

(5) depth of cover.

d. Pump, if provided, details as referenced in Section R317-4-14 Appendix B.

e. If an alternative LUWD system is designed, include all pertinent information to allow plan review and permitting for compliance with this rule.

C. Plans Submitted.

1. All applicants requesting plan approval for a LUWD shall submit two copies of the above required information to enable the division to retain one copy as a permanent record.

2. Applications may be rejected if proper information is not submitted.

5.3. Construction Permit Required.

No person shall make or construct any device for treatment or discharge of wastewater without first receiving a permit to do so from the director.

 

R317-5-6. Design Requirements.

6.1. Shall meet the requirements of Section R317-4-6, with these exceptions:

A. When a LUWD serves multiple single family dwellings the wastewater flow shall be estimated at 400 gpd per dwelling.

B. Minimum separation distance from the bottom of the absorption trenches to the anticipated maximum ground water table is 48 inches. If a mound, sand lined trench, or packed bed pretreatment unit is designed and installed on the LUWD system, the horizontal separation distance may be reduced to 24 inches.

6.2. Components Required in a LUWD System:

A. A septic tank;

B. An effluent filter;

C. A pressurized subsurface disposal system.

1. This may be an absorption field, deep wall trenches, absorption beds, or, for packed bed media applications, drip irrigation dispersal, depending on location, topography, soil conditions and maximum ground water level.

2. Pressurized systems require cleanouts at the end of pressurized laterals and typically require a dosing chamber or dosing tank.

3. The Utah Guidance for Performance, Application, Design, Operation & Maintenance: Pressure Distribution Systems document shall be used for design requirements, along with the following:

a. Dosing pumps, controls and alarms shall comply with Section R317-4-14 Appendix B.

b. Pressure distribution piping.

i. All pressure transport, manifold, lateral piping, and fittings shall meet PVC Schedule 40 standards or equivalent.

ii. The ends of lateral piping shall be constructed with sweep elbows or an equivalent method to bring the end of the pipe to the final grade. The ends of the pipe shall be provided with threaded plugs, caps, or other devices acceptable to the division to allow for access and flushing of the lateral.

D. Accessibility components to insure proper maintenance and servicing. These include that all tanks shall have access risers to the surface of the ground; and absorption field inspection ports.

E. Additional components may also be required depending on the waste stream characteristics and the need to provide adequate protection to groundwater. These components may include pretreatment devices such as grease traps, or may involve secondary treatment using packed bed media systems.

 

R317-5-7. Construction and Installation.

Shall meet the requirements of Section R317-4-7.

 

R317-5-8. Final Inspection and Authorization to Use.

8.1. Final inspection.

Upon completion of construction, but before backfilling, the system designer must notify the division of completion and schedule a final inspection with the division. Where the local health department has the authority to issue operating permits they shall be included in the final inspection. The final inspection shall meet the requirements of Section R317-4-8. No wastewater may be introduced into a LUWD system until an authorization to use has been issued by the division.

8.2. Authorization to Use

The following documents, sealed by the engineer, must be provided to the division in order to receive authorization to use:

A. Written certification that the system was installed in accordance with the construction permit and any approved change orders.

B. Two record drawings of the completed system.

C. Two Operation & Maintenance Manuals. Manuals must include details of:

1. individuals of contact for the installed system;

2. list of all key components of the system;

3. maintenance and service instructions of each component;

4. schedule of maintenance inspections and servicing.

D. Written recommendation to the owner to place the facilities into service, pending issuance of the authorization to use by the division.

 

R317-5-9. Operation and Maintenance.

9.1. Operation and maintenance shall be provided by the owner to ensure the disposal system is functioning properly at all times.

9.2. The owner is responsible for maintaining a LUWD system and for performing periodic inspections, servicing and monitoring of its system as detailed in the issued operating permit, including the following:

A. Any new system installed after April 2009 must have a written operation and maintenance manual document describing the treatment and disposal system and outlining routine maintenance procedures, including checklists and maintenance logs needed for proper operation of the system.

B. Each LUWD Conventional System shall be assessed after the first year of operation and annually thereafter.

C. Each LUWD Pressure Distribution System shall be inspected as outlined in Section R317-4-23 Tables 7.1 and 7.2.

D. LUWD Alternative Systems.

1. Each alternative system shall be inspected as outlined in Section R317-4-13 Tables 7.1 and 7.2.

2. Each packed bed media system shall be sampled a minimum of every six months as outlined in Section R317-4-13 Table 7.3.

a. The grab sample shall be taken before discharge to an absorption system.

b. Effluent not meeting the standards of Section R317-4-13 Table 7.3, shall be followed with two successive weekly tests of the same type within a 30 day period from the first exceedance.

3. If two successive samples exceed the minimum standards, the system shall be deemed to be malfunctioning, and shall require further evaluation and a corrective action plan, see Subsection R317-5-3.9.

 

R317-5-10. Operating Permits and Annual Inspection Reports.

10.1. Operating Permit required.

An operating permit is required for all LUWD systems to monitor that proper operation and maintenance is occurring for the protection of the environment and public health. The operating permit shall be issued by the director or, by delegated authority, the local health department having jurisdiction, and shall be effective for a period not to exceed 5 years from the date of issuance.

10.2. Local Health Department Authority to Issue Operating Permits.

Local health departments may request delegated authority to administer the operating permit program. The request must include an agreement to implement and enforce inspection, servicing, monitoring, and reporting requirements of this rule. The local health department must submit an annual report on or before September 1 of each calendar year, to the division containing:

A. A list of LUWD systems under delegation.

B. A summary listing the compliance status of each system, showing those systems that are currently failing, and those systems that have been repaired.

C. A summary of any enforcement actions taken, identifying those actions that are still pending, and those that been resolved.

10.3. Annual Inspection Report.

The owner of a LUWD system shall summit an annual inspection report covering the period of July 1 to June 30, the "reporting year", to the permitting agency no later than August 1 of each year. In this report, the owner shall report on all requirements listed in the operating permit. As a minimum, the report shall include the following items:

A. Facility name and address; owner name, address, and phone number;

B. List of facility components, e.g., septic tank, pump tank, gravel drainfield trench, gravelless chambers, pressure drainfield, etc.;

C. Design flow in gallons per day and number and type of connections;

D. Type of waste treated and disposed, i.e., residential, restaurant, other commercial establishment, etc.;

E. Checklist of inspections performed including the date of the inspection and a list of findings. The report must include, where pertinent:

1. measured sludge and scum levels;

2. date tanks were last pumped;

3. verify pumps, floats; and control panel are operating as designed;

4. date pump filter last cleaned;

5. date pressure laterals last cleaned and flushed and squirt height recorded;

6. any surfacing in absorption field; and

7. any observed or suspected system malfunction;

F. Packed Bed media system sampling results, where pertinent;

G. Name of the certified individual per Rule R317-11 conducting the inspection;

H. Signature of owner or certified operator, and date.

 

KEY: water pollution, large underground wastewater, sewerage, engineering

Date of Enactment or Last Substantive Amendment: [September 24, 2015]2014

Notice of Continuation: June 18, 2012

Authorizing, and Implemented or Interpreted Law: 19-5

 


Additional Information

More information about a Notice of Proposed Rule is available online.

The Portable Document Format (PDF) version of the Bulletin is the official version. The PDF version of this issue is available at https://rules.utah.gov/publicat/bull-pdf/2014/b20140215.pdf. The HTML edition of the Bulletin is a convenience copy. Any discrepancy between the PDF version and HTML version is resolved in favor of the PDF version.

Text to be deleted is struck through and surrounded by brackets ([example]). Text to be added is underlined (example).  Older browsers may not depict some or any of these attributes on the screen or when the document is printed.

For questions regarding the content or application of this rule, please contact Judy Etherington at the above address, by phone at 801-536-4344, by FAX at 801-536-4301, or by Internet E-mail at jetherington@utah.gov.