DAR File No. 38464

Human Resource Management, Administration

Rule R477-101

Administrative Law Judge Conduct Committee

Notice of Proposed Rule

(Amendment)

DAR File No.: 38464
Filed: 04/25/2014 12:43:35 PM

RULE ANALYSIS

Purpose of the rule or reason for the change:

The purpose of this amendment is to renumber subsections of the rule and clarify notice of the complaint procedure.

Summary of the rule or change:

The changes renumber the sections so that there is uniformity across all rule sections and require that agencies notify parties of the complaint procedure.

State statutory or constitutional authorization for this rule:

• Section 67-19e-101

Anticipated cost or savings to:

the state budget:

These changes are administrative and do not directly impact state budgets.

local governments:

This rule only affects the executive branch of state government and will have no impact on local government.

small businesses:

This rule only affects the executive branch of state government and will have no impact on small businesses.

persons other than small businesses, businesses, or local governmental entities:

This rule only affects the executive branch of state government and will have no impact on other persons. This rule has no financial impact on state employees.

Compliance costs for affected persons:

There is no direct compliance cost for these amendments because the changes are simply renumbering with other small administrative changes.

Comments by the department head on the fiscal impact the rule may have on businesses:

Rules published by the Department of Human Resource Management (DHRM) have no direct effect on businesses or any entity outside state government. DHRM has authority to write rules only to the extent allowed by the Utah Personnel Management Act, Title 67, Chapter 19. This act limits the provisions of career service and these rules to employees of the executive branch of state government.

Debbie Cragun, Executive Director

The full text of this rule may be inspected, during regular business hours, at the Division of Administrative Rules, or at:

Human Resource Management
Administration
Room 2120 STATE OFFICE BLDG
450 N MAIN ST
SALT LAKE CITY, UT 84114-1201

Direct questions regarding this rule to:

• Kurt Bradburn at the above address, by phone at 801-538-3206, by FAX at , or by Internet E-mail at kbradburn@utah.gov

Interested persons may present their views on this rule by submitting written comments to the address above no later than 5:00 p.m. on:

06/16/2014

Interested persons may attend a public hearing regarding this rule:

• 05/22/2014 10:00 AM, Senate Bldg, Spruce Room, 420 N State St, Salt Lake City, UT

This rule may become effective on:

06/30/2014

Authorized by:

Debbie Cragun, Executive Director

R477. Human Resource Management, Administration.

R477-101. Administrative Law Judge Conduct Committee.

R477-101-1. Authority and Purpose.

This rule is enacted pursuant to Utah Code Section 67-19e-104, requiring the Department of Human Resource Management to establish rules governing minimum performance standards for administrative law judges, procedures for addressing and reviewing complaints against administrative law judges, standards for complaints, and standards of conduct for administrative law judges.

 

R477-101-2. Definitions.

In addition to the terms defined in Utah Code Section 67-19e-102:

(1) "Administrative Law Judge" (ALJ) includes Hearing Officers employed or contracted by a state agency that meet the criteria described in Utah Code Section 67-19e-102(1)(a).

(2) "Chair" means the Executive Director, Department of Human Resource Management, or designee.

(3) "Code of Conduct" means the Model Code of Judicial Conduct for State Administrative Law Judges, National Association of Administrative Law Judges (November 1993) incorporated by reference.

(4) "Committee" means the Administrative Law Judge Committee created in Utah Code Section 67-19e-108.

(5) "Committee Meeting" means a proceeding at which a Complaint is presented to the Committee by the investigator. Respondent ALJ shall also have the opportunity to appear and speak regarding the Complaint and its allegations.

(6) "Complaint" means a written document filed with the Department pursuant to Utah Administrative Code R477-101-401 alleging Misconduct by an ALJ.

(7) "Department" means the Department of Human Resource Management.

(8) "Final Agency Action" occurs when the substantive rights or obligations of litigants in an administrative proceeding have been determined or legal consequences flow from a determination and when the agency decision is not preliminary, preparatory, procedural or intermediate.

(9) "Full investigation" means that portion of an investigation where the Respondent ALJ may respond, in writing, to specific allegations identified in a Complaint. A Full Investigation may also include, but is not limited to: examination by the Investigator of documents, correspondence, hearing records, transcripts or tapes; interviews of the complainant, counsel, hearing staff, Respondent ALJ, interested parties, and other witnesses.

(10) "Good cause" means a cause or reason in law, equity or justice that provides responsible basis for action or a decision.

(11) "Interested Party" means an individual or entity who participated in an event or proceeding giving rise to a Complaint against the Respondent ALJ.

(12) "Investigator" means a person employed by the department to perform investigations mandated under Utah Code Section 67-19e-107 and present information at the Committee Meeting.

(13) "Misconduct" means a violation of the Code of Conduct or Utah Code Section 67-19e-101 et seq.

(14) "Preliminary Investigation" means that portion of an investigation conducted by the Department upon receipt of a Complaint. A Preliminary Investigation may include, but is not limited to: examination of documents, correspondence, interviews of the complainant, counsel, hearing staff, and other witnesses.

(15) "Respondent ALJ" means an ALJ against whom a Complaint is filed.

 

R477-101-3. Jurisdiction.

(1) Administrative Law Judges. The Committee has jurisdiction over ALJs to investigate, review, hear, and make recommendations regarding Complaints filed against ALJs.

(2) Former ALJs. The Committee has continuing jurisdiction over former ALJs regarding allegations that Misconduct occurred during service as an ALJ if a Complaint is received before the ALJ's appointment concludes.

 

R477-101-4. Records Classification and Retention.

(1) Records prepared by and for the Committee, including all Complaints, investigative reports, recommendations, and votes on recommended action against an ALJ are classified as protected under Utah Code Section 63G-2-305.

(2) Committee records shall be maintained by the department for a period of three years following the conclusion of any Committee activity.

 

R477-101-[201]5. Committee.

(1) The Executive Director or designee shall serve as Chair of the Committee, and appoint four Executive Directors or their designees to serve on the Committee.

(2) Only Executive Directors of agencies that employ or contract with ALJs may serve on the Committee.

(3) If a Department investigation establishes a Complaint requires further action, the Executive Director and Chair shall convene the Committee.

(4) An Executive Director of the agency that employs or contracts with the Respondent ALJ may not participate in a Committee proceeding involving the Respondent ALJ.

(5) After convening the Committee, the Department shall provide a copy of the Complaint and its investigative results to the Committee and the Respondent ALJ.

(6) Within 30 days of the date the Committee is convened on a complaint the Committee shall schedule a Committee Meeting. At the Committee Meeting the Respondent ALJ shall be given the opportunity to appear, speak and present documents in response to a Complaint.

(7) Committee members may attend Committee meetings in person, by telephone, by videoconference, or by other means approved in advance by the Chair.

(8) After consideration of all information provided at the Committee Meeting, the Committee shall dispose of the Complaint by issuing a decision or report with a recommendation to the agency containing:

(a) a brief description of the Complaint and the investigative results;

(b) findings, and;

(c) recommendations.

(9) Committee members shall not, individually or collectively, engage in ex parte communications about proceedings with complainants, witnesses, or ALJs.

 

R477-101-[202]6. Duties of the Chair.

(1) The Chair shall:

(a) receive, acknowledge receipt of and review Complaints;

(b) notify complainants about the status and disposition of their Complaints,

(c) make recommendations to the Committee regarding further proceedings or the disposition of a Complaint;

(d) stay investigation(s) or committee proceedings pending Final Agency Action of the matter giving rise to the Complaint against the Respondent ALJ;

(e) maintain records of the Committee's operations and actions;

(f) compile data to aid in the administration of the Committee's operations and actions;

(g) prepare and distribute an annual report of the Committee's operations and actions;

(h) direct the operations of the Committee's office, and supervise other members of the Committee's staff;

(i) make available to the public the laws, rules, and procedures of the Committee and its operations;

(j) consider requests for extension of time periods and, upon a showing of Good Cause, grant such requests for a period not to exceed 20 days for each request.

(2) Subject to the duty to direct and supervise, the Chair may delegate any of the foregoing duties to other members of the Committee's staff.

 

R477-101-[301]7. Code of Conduct.

(1) ALJs shall comply with the Model Code of Judicial Conduct for State Administrative Law Judges, National Association of Administrative Law Judges.

(2) In order to suit a specific agency need, an agency may make an addendum or modification to the Code of Conduct. Any such addendum or modification shall be specific to their agency. In addition, any addendum or modification to the Code of Conduct must be reviewed and approved by the Committee before being implemented. The Committee may be convened for the purpose of reviewing any proposed addendum or modification.

 

R477-101-[401]8. Filing Procedure.

(1) Each agency shall include a copy of DHRM Rule R477-101 in the administrative rule materials that they provide to parties, or shall otherwise make them readily available to parties, at the commencement of administrative proceedings.

([1]2) An individual who alleges a violation of the Code of Conduct or otherwise has a Complaint against an ALJ may file a timely Complaint with the Department. To be timely a Complaint must be in writing and filed with the Department within 20 working days of Final Administrative Action in the matter in which the individual is an Interested Party.

([2]3) Complaints filed with the Department are deemed filed on the date actually received by the Department. The Department shall date-stamp all Complaints on the date received. All filing and other time periods are based upon the Department's working days.

([3]4) Complaints must contain specific facts and allegations of Misconduct and must be signed by the person filing the Complaint or by the person's authorized representative. Complaints shall also contain the name, address, and telephone number of the complainant, and the name, business address, and telephone number of the representative, if a party or person is being represented.

([4]5) The Department will give written notice to both the complainant and Respondent ALJ when a Complaint is received.

 

R477-101-[402]9. Investigation.

(1) Preliminary Investigation.

(a) The Department shall review all timely filed Complaints and shall, regardless of whether the allegations contained therein would constitute misconduct if true, conduct a Preliminary Investigation.

(b) If the Preliminary Investigation determines that the Complaint is untimely, frivolous, without merit of, or if the Complaint merely indicates disagreement with the Respondent ALJ's decision, without further alleged Misconduct, the Complaint may be similarly dismissed without further action.

(c) If, after a Preliminary Investigation is completed, there is a reasonable basis to find Misconduct occurred, the Investigator shall initiate a Full Investigation.

(2) Full Investigation.

Within ten days after a determination to conduct a Full Investigation is made, the Investigator shall notify the Respondent ALJ that a Full Investigation is being conducted. The notice shall:

(a) inform the Respondent ALJ of the specific facts and allegations being investigated and the canons or statutory provisions allegedly violated;

(b) inform the Respondent ALJ that the investigation may be expanded if appropriate;

(c) invite the Respondent ALJ to respond to the Complaint in writing within 10 working days;

(d) include a copy of the Complaint, the Preliminary Investigation report(s), and any other documentation reviewed in determining whether to authorize a Full Investigation; and

(e) unless continued by the Chair, Full Investigations shall be completed within three months of the determination to conduct a Full Investigation.

 

R477-101-[403]10. Full Investigative Findings.

Results of the investigation shall be provided to the Chair, who shall determine whether to convene a Committee Meeting.

 

R477-101-[501]11. Notice.

(1) If after review of the Full Investigative result and findings the Chair determines the Complaint is factually or legally insufficient to establish Misconduct, the Chair shall similarly dismiss the Complaint and take no further action.

(2) If after review of the Full Investigative result and findings the Chair determines the Complaint requires further action, the Chair shall convene the Committee and order a Committee Meeting be scheduled.

(3) After convening the Committee the Chair shall provide Respondent ALJ written notice of the ALJ's right to appear, speak, and present documents at the Committee Meeting. The Chair shall also provide the Respondent ALJ with a copy of the Complaint and the results of the Department's investigation.

(4) Notice that a Committee has been convened and a Committee Meeting ordered shall be made by personal service or certified mail upon the Respondent ALJ or the Respondent ALJ's representative. Service of all other notices or papers may be regular mail.

(5) Within 20 days after receiving written notice from the Chair that a Committee has been convened the Respondent ALJ may provide the Committee a written response to the Complaint.

(6) After receipt of the Respondent ALJ's response of after expiration of the time to respond the Committee shall, in consultation with the ALJ, schedule a Committee Meeting. The Committee shall notify the ALJ in writing of the date, time, and place of the Committee Meeting. Unless continued for Good Cause, Committee Meetings shall be held within four months of the date a Committee is convened on a Complaint.

(7) No later than 20 days before the scheduled Committee Meeting the Chair shall provide the Respondent ALJ with copies of all documents proposed for use at the Committee Meeting or to be relied upon in making its report and recommendation.

(8) Respondent ALJ shall be entitled to representation at every stage of the Committee proceedings or the Committee Meeting.

(9) Neither the Utah Rules of Evidence nor the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure apply in Committee proceedings.

 

R477-101-[502]12. Effect of Respondent ALJ's Resignation or Retirement during Proceeding.

If the Respondent ALJ resigns or retires during the proceedings, the Committee shall determine whether to proceed or dismiss the proceedings.

 

R477-101-[503]13. Committee Meetings.

(1) The Chair shall rule on all motions or objections raised during a Committee Meeting, set reasonable limits on the statements or documents presented, including any statements from the complainant. The Chair may limit the time allowed for the presentation of information, may bifurcate any and all issues to be considered, and may make any and all other rulings regarding any Committee proceeding or Committee Meeting.

(2) To hold a Committee Meeting there must be at least 3 members of the Committee present.

(3) The Respondent ALJ shall be permitted to present information to, make statements and produce witnesses for the Committee's consideration.

(4) Committee members may ask questions of any witness including the Respondent ALJ.

(5) Immediately following the conclusion of the Committee Meeting, the Committee shall deliberate and decide whether there is sufficient evidence the Respondent ALJ violated the Code of Conduct or otherwise engaged in Misconduct. Any such decision shall require a majority vote of the participating Committee members.

(6) Committee decisions shall be supported by a preponderance of the evidence.

(7) Within 30 days of the conclusion of the Committee Meeting, the Chair shall prepare a memorandum decision or report, with a recommendation for any proposed personnel action(s), and shall forward the decision and recommendation to the Respondent ALJ and the agency head of the Respondent ALJ.

(8) After deliberation, if the Committee finds insufficient evidence or reason to determine Misconduct occurred, the complaint shall be dismissed.

 

R477-101-[504]14. Discipline.

(1) At any time after the commencement of a Full Investigation and before any Committee action, the ALJ may admit to any or all of the allegations in exchange for a stated sanction. The admission shall be submitted to the Committee for a recommendation.

(2) Any corrective and/or disciplinary action taken against a career service employee by the employing agency shall be implemented in accordance with applicable Department or state rule(s) governing discipline.

 

R477-101-[505]15. Reinstatement of Proceedings.

(1) Reinstatement upon Request by Complainant.

(a) If a Complaint is dismissed, the complainant may, within 20 days of the date of the letter notifying the complainant of the dismissal, file a written request that the Committee reinstate the Complaint. The request shall include the specific grounds upon which reinstatement is sought.

(b) The request shall be presented to the Committee at the next available Meeting of the Committee, at which time the Committee shall determine whether to reinstate the Complaint.

(c) A determination not to reinstate the Complaint is not reviewable.

(2) Reinstatement by the Chair.

(a) If the Committee dismisses a Complaint, the Chair may, at any time upon the receipt of newly discovered evidence, request that the Committee reinstate the Complaint. The request shall include the specific grounds upon which the reinstatement is sought.

(b) The request shall be presented to the Committee at the next available Meeting of the Committee, at which time the Committee shall determine whether to reinstate the Complaint.

 

R477-101-[601]16. Performance Standard.

(1) The following minimum performance standards shall apply to all ALJ's:

(a) The ALJ shall have no more than one agency disciplinary action or one Committee recommendation for disciplinary action during the ALJ's four-year evaluation cycle; and

(b) The ALJ shall receive an average score of no less than 65% on each survey category as provided in Utah Code 67-19e-106.

(2) For any question that does not use the numerical scale, the Committee shall establish the minimum performance standard. Any established performance standard shall be substantially equivalent to the standard required by Utah Code Section 67-19e-105.

 

R477-101-[602]17. Performance Surveys.

(1) Initial performance surveys shall be conducted by the department beginning January 1, 2014, based on current ALJs' assignment effective date. Current ALJ's will be divided into four approximately equal groups based on length of tenure in the ALJ position. The most tenured group will be surveyed first, with the next tenured group being surveyed beginning January 1 of the following calendar year, until the four-year survey cycle is established.

(2) Survey respondents may include:

(a) Attorneys who have appeared before the administrative law judge as counsel in the proceeding;

(b) Staff who have worked with the administrative law judge; and

(c) Any other person that has appeared on record before the administrative law judge, including but not limited to pro se parties and witnesses, in the proceeding.

([2]3) Survey results shall be maintained by the department and shall not be maintained in the ALJ's personnel file.

([3]4) Survey results shall be made available to the ALJ's supervisor for consideration in completing annual performance evaluations.

 

KEY: administrative law judges, conduct committee

Date of Enactment or Last Substantive Amendment: [January 14, ]2014

Authorizing, and Implemented or Interpreted Law: 67-19e-101 through 67-19e-109